Request a Free Insurance Quote Today

Compare Rates from 27 Insurance Companies!

Insurance Type

Welcome to Atlantic Agency

We are an independent insurance firm dedicated to providing you with quality personal and commercial insurance programs. We have also partnered with over 47 insurance companies to adapt an insurance program to fit your needs and the needs of your family, while keeping our prices competitive.

We are experts in providing "Outstanding Sales & Customer Service" to one client at a time. Let's face it no one likes to deal with insurance until you need it, we are here to make the experience as easy and effortless at possible. Our number #1 goal is to make your experience with us friendly, easy and professional.

Long Island & New York State Homeowners Insurance

Atlanic Agency's agents are experts in homeowners and renters insurance on Long Island and in New York. We work with carriers rated A+ by AM Best for Nassau and Suffolk County homeowners in NY. Whatever type of home you have, we can provide the right homeowners insurance at the right price.

The Right Insurance Company

For People Who Want Unrivalled Protection They Can Rely On.

  • Are you tired of getting the run around from your current company?
  • Are you put on hold indefinitely?
  • Does it take 3 phone calls to 3 different companies to solve all of your insurance needs?

Finally – exclusive insurance programs that can eliminate dangerous gaps in your protection and make your life easier – instantly!


Learn more »

Our Huntington Office has moved.
     You can find us at:

1469 Deer Park Ave. N Babylon, NY 11703-1208!
Defensive Driving Course


From Our Clients...

Eric and his team at Atlantic Agency Insurance are a very professional and honest team! Our company is very impressed with the quick turnaround with all of our requests. Both the professionalism and knowledge of the field really helped meet the needs of our company. Thanks to Atlantic Agency Insurance we can focus on working while we trust we have Eric and his team supporting our business! - Carlos Mejia, President of M&Q Steel Corp

"I was prevoiusly quoted over $4,000.00 dollars, here the price was half that and the customer service was excellent and prompt. I will definitely recommend this company to others." - Erik B., E. Moriches, NY

"Your staff is Proffessional, Efficent and Knowledgeable. They completed my transaction quickly and answered all questions promptly and clearly. I would recommend this office to others." - Lisa C., Southampton, NY

Read More »


BBB Accredited Business

Our Insurance Partners

Our Partners